MLB defense vs position: how starting pitchers fare against each lineup

This page is loading and it needs JavaScript. The written page below is served without it.

Defense vs position, as MLB research reads it, runs the other way round. A lineup does not defend a position the way a basketball or football defense does, and what it "allows" to a fielder is mostly where he bats. What does carry from game to game is how a lineup treats the pitcher facing it. So each row below is a club’s lineup, and the figures are what opposing starting pitchers recorded against it per start, counting outings of four innings or more between two major league clubs, each start measured against that pitcher’s own other starts, with recent starts counting more.

Window: the MLB 2026 season, games logged from Feb 20, 2026 to Oct 28, 2026. Rebuilt daily; as of Nov 20, 2026.

Starting pitchers against each MLB lineup

How much the matchup has mattered: lineups one standard deviation apart have moved starting pitchers' strikeouts by about 0.51 per start, against a league average of 5.0. Reliability 57%: most of the spread is a stable difference between lineups, not noise.

In strikeouts, starting pitchers facing the Cincinnati Reds have averaged 6.2 per start, the most of the 30 ranked, against a league average of 5.0; against the Toronto Blue Jays they have averaged 3.6, the fewest.

MLB 2026 season, per start, rank in brackets (1st is the most recorded against that lineup); rating 0 to 100 on strikeouts, 100 is the most recorded against that lineup
LineupStrikeouts per startHits allowed per startOuts per startStartsRating
Cincinnati Reds6.2 (1st)4.1 (27th)16.8 (4th)147100
Los Angeles Angels6.2 (2nd)4.3 (24th)16.4 (12th)15297
Chicago White Sox6.1 (3rd)4.3 (25th)15.4 (26th)15093
Texas Rangers5.9 (4th)4.8 (13th)17.1 (1st)14690
St. Louis Cardinals5.7 (5th)4.1 (26th)17.0 (2nd)14686
Milwaukee Brewers5.5 (6th)5.0 (8th)14.6 (30th)15983
New York Yankees5.4 (7th)3.9 (29th)15.8 (23rd)16079
Baltimore Orioles5.4 (8th)4.5 (21st)16.6 (7th)14376
Houston Astros5.3 (9th)5.0 (9th)16.0 (20th)16772
Seattle Mariners5.3 (10th)4.5 (22nd)15.9 (21st)15169
Pittsburgh Pirates5.2 (11th)4.7 (16th)16.5 (8th)15566
Colorado Rockies5.2 (12th)5.0 (7th)16.7 (5th)14862
Kansas City Royals5.1 (13th)5.4 (1st)16.2 (16th)15159
Atlanta Braves5.1 (14th)3.8 (30th)16.7 (6th)15955
Boston Red Sox5.0 (15th)4.0 (28th)15.7 (25th)15752
San Francisco Giants5.0 (16th)4.9 (11th)16.1 (17th)15448
Detroit Tigers5.0 (17th)4.6 (17th)15.0 (28th)14845
New York Mets4.9 (18th)5.0 (10th)15.8 (22nd)16041
Miami Marlins4.9 (19th)4.6 (18th)16.2 (15th)15038
Washington Nationals4.8 (20th)4.8 (12th)16.2 (14th)14834
Chicago Cubs4.8 (21st)4.4 (23rd)16.4 (11th)14931
Minnesota Twins4.6 (22nd)5.3 (3rd)16.1 (19th)15528
Philadelphia Phillies4.4 (23rd)5.2 (5th)16.8 (3rd)16224
Arizona Diamondbacks4.3 (24th)4.6 (20th)15.8 (24th)16021
Los Angeles Dodgers4.3 (25th)4.8 (14th)15.0 (27th)15017
Athletics4.2 (26th)5.2 (4th)16.5 (9th)16114
San Diego Padres4.2 (27th)5.4 (2nd)14.9 (29th)16110
Cleveland Guardians3.9 (28th)4.8 (15th)16.3 (13th)1547
Tampa Bay Rays3.9 (29th)4.6 (19th)16.5 (10th)1603
Toronto Blue Jays3.6 (30th)5.1 (6th)16.1 (18th)1570
League average5.04.816.3

How to read the MLB table

  • Adjusted for who played: each game is compared with that player’s own other games this season, so a defense that met a run of stars is not marked down for it. Pace and minutes are not adjusted.
  • Recent games count more: a game 8 of this lineup’s games ago counts half as much as its latest.
  • Ranks are per stat and per position only. None of them is an overall defensive rank.
  • A team needs 5 starts against it before it is ranked; below that the average is shown without a rank.
  • A rank describes games already played. It is not a forecast of the next one, and a high figure suits an Over and works against an Under in equal measure.

MLB defense vs position, common questions

What does defense vs position mean for MLB props?

For MLB it is read as pitcher against lineup: how many strikeouts, hits and outs starting pitchers have recorded per start against each club. It describes how a lineup has treated the pitchers it faced, which is context for a pitcher prop, not a prediction of it.

How are the MLB ranks worked out?

Every logged game by a player at the position against that team is compared with that player’s own other games this season, the differences are averaged with recent games weighted more, and the result is added to the league average. Teams are ranked by it, 1st as the most allowed; teams under the player-game floor are listed without a rank. Pace and minutes are not adjusted. Each table also says how much of the spread between teams is real and how much is noise.

Does a team that allows the most make the Over a good bet?

Not on its own. A rank tells you what happened in games already played, against whichever players that team happened to face. The price on offer already reflects much of it, and this page says nothing about whether a given price is worth taking. Parlay Builder is research: it does not take bets and promises no outcome.

How often is this page updated?

Daily. The table is rebuilt from official box scores each morning, and the window line above it says which season and dates it covers.

Where to go from here

You must be 21+ (or older, where your jurisdiction sets a higher age) to bet. If gambling stops being fun, call or text 1-800-GAMBLER (1-800-426-2537) for free, confidential help.

Odds and lines come from licensed data feeds and refresh on a schedule; hit rates and grades are Parlay Builder’s own calculations.